In my experience the best way to play this is with unusual facts about yourself, trying to trick the guessers about which is the most (or least) unusual. Saying, "I like Red, I like Blue, I like Green" is somewhat boring in my opinion.
OK, my turn:
1. I've played Final Fantasy VI
2. I've played Fallout 2
3. I've played Zelda: Wind Waker
I will say 2. I say this based on the fact that the other two are console games whereas 2 is a PC game.
[mod]I've removed your list for when you have it right, because its rude. Wait and hear if you got it right, then post your turn. [/mod]