Mafia 10 (End)

Jimj's inactivity is relatively explainable, so a vote for him would be a slight overkill on 'dealing with no-posters' if that makes any sense. Just starting a discussion, not defending the highly suspicious no-posters.

not defending the highly suspicious no-posters.

What do you mean with "highly suspicious"? With roughly half of everyone playing being inactive, not posting isn't that indicative of scum since a lot of townies are doing it as well.
Those townies might be kind of useless, but that's not the point.

@everyone
What is your opinion on inactive players, and what do you think about PP's analysis?

PP's analysis was pretty dead on in my opinion... No poster's should be punished, maybe not as harshly as I would suggest, but they definitely should. They joined the game for a reason, to play, not to sit around and watch the action unfold.

What do you think about PP's analysis?

So that'd mean, like mentioned before in the spoiler, vote:Purple Pineapple

Blahblahblah Mr. Fourrier analysis: 0/5 scum rating, without reason. It seems you can't think of a reason for that rating. I'd say vote:Purple Pineapple.

He's suspicious for not suspecting himself? I don't even...

just FYI, when I typed that ALL CAPS message, I was 40,000 feet over Spain and on a mobile phone, trying not to let the air hostess see. that's why it was in ALL CAPS. I unfortunately forgot the rule regarding such.

In case anyone didn't read it, it was: (w/o caps so LP doesn't kill me)
"ohmygoodnessiamsosorry
iconfirmalready
amiingame?!"

He's suspicious for not suspecting himself? I don't even...

More for having no reason at all.

Oh, and P.S. Razzorman, i finally know what's wrong with you: You don't lack intelligence but common sense!

Oh, and P.S. Razzorman, i finally know what's wrong with you: You don't lack intelligence but common sense!

WELL THATS JUST HOW I ROLL

Quote from: Razzorman on May 07, 2010, 20:58:25

He's suspicious for not suspecting himself? I don't even...

More for having no reason at all.

Everyone is going to claim to be town anyways.
It's just that the more you try to convince people that you are a townie, the less likely you are to actually be one.
If you are town, you should demonstrate that by your actions.

(plus, I'm prety sure that pp was being sarcastic)

I agree completely, sarcasm is pretty common among us nifforumers.

In response to Com-B analysis: Yeah, that's pretty suspicious. I can't even convince myself i'm not scum. But, if i have a mafia role, i'd betray the other one.

Yeah.. except LimeLemon's already dead.

Blahblahblah Mr. Fourrier analysis: 0/5 scum rating, without reason. It seems you can't think of a reason for that rating. I'd say vote:Purple Pineapple.

Okay. Let's suppose for a moment that I was scum. Would I just go, "Hey guys. I'm scum. So you should all lynch me."
A) That wouldn't help me, because everyone would vote me.
B) Even if I said that I was joking, it would raise unnecessary attention which typically leads to at least one vote, which in this particular game means a lynch.

Spoiler: I'll answer the rest with a Phoenix Wright-ish scene. (click to show/hide)

Cross Examination
-- My analysis on the people --

FOURNIER: Com-B is inactive and stubborn, making him suspicious.
(blahness goes on until...)
FOURNIER: Those no-posters are suspicious.
(Present > Razzorman's testimony)
Objection!
COM-B: You claim that they are suspicious... why?
COM-B: A lot of townies are doing it as well!
FOURNIER: So this means?
COM-B: (Crud. Didn't see that coming.)
(Some other guy's statement goes here)

If you're trying to make a point here, don't make everyone read between the lines.

(plus, I'm prety sure that pp was being sarcastic)

What do you mean by sarcastic? I was stating my honest opinion of myself in the game. (Of course you can't know that for a fact, but I do.)

Quote from: Razzorman on May 08, 2010, 00:37:01

(plus, I'm prety sure that pp was being sarcastic)

What do you mean by sarcastic? I was stating my honest opinion of myself in the game. (Of course you can't know that for a fact, but I do.)

I just thought that "it's a fact that I'm a townie" seemed like a bit of an overstatement, so I guessed that it was sarcasm.

Anyways, since nobody is playing, and nobody seems that suspicious at the moment, I think we should lynch the inactives.
Vote: Yukabacera

@Jim
You didn't actually say anything in your last post. What is your general opinion on the game?

@Straightflame

Spoiler: I'll answer the rest with a Phoenix Wright-ish scene. (click to show/hide)

Cross Examination
-- My analysis on the people --

FOURNIER: Com-B is inactive and stubborn, making him suspicious.
(blahness goes on until...)
FOURNIER: Those no-posters are suspicious.
(Present > Razzorman's testimony)
Objection!
COM-B: You claim that they are suspicious... why?
COM-B: A lot of townies are doing it as well!
FOURNIER: So this means?
COM-B: (Crud. Didn't see that coming.)
(Some other guy's statement goes here)

I've never played Ace attorney (and I never really watched any of those youtube spoofs either). Mind explaining what this means?

@Razzor:Didn't I? *checks* Oh sorry, I didn't.

my opinion on the game: only two people are suspicious in my mind; Yukabacera, as mentioned before, and SF, a bit, for possibly trying to say PP is suspicious for saying that he isn't Mafia. which does seem kinda silly, seeing as probably everyone in this game is going to claim that they aren't Mafia if asked. (that's the whole point of the game)

However (and please don't think that this is me defending him), I think that we should give Yuka the benefit of the doubt, as he (as claimed in his very first post) knows nothing of this game, and probably doesn't know the whole "post or die" thing. I think that the mod should go and prod him, and if he still doesn't respond, then he is lynchworthy.

*stops to catch breath*

@mod: If StraightFlame doesn't unvote does that mean I die?

@mod: If StraightFlame doesn't unvote does that mean I die?

Pff no. First, Yuka has more votes then you. Second, the day ends not until Friday.

Also, OCEAN SUNFISH.