* Humor: 14/18Many random and funny situations. Cutscenes are great, the normal ending cracked me up
One of the jokes was used a bit too many times, tho.
* Gameplay/Polish: 10/12Custom tilesets, custom objects, no wallswims/void, full use of flags... it shows a lot of work. It's a small level but there are a few interesting challenges/puzzles that keep you entertained for quite a while. The only problem I found is that you can skip a few difficult screens by jumping on a certain spot and climbing a shaft (instead of going through the intended challenges). There are also a few minor issues, such as the lack of an info screen and some minor glitches (e.g., when you pick up the bottle for the second time), but nothing really annoying or game-breaking.
* Originality: 7/10While the main idea (rescuing your cat) is really simple and it's something that has been done before, the plot has quite a few interesting twists this time
* Bonus for related challenge/puzzle: 4/5The puzzle on the rubber duck screen was pretty funny. Also, I loved the text for the "fake puzzles" and failed attempts
Overall: 35/40