Mafia 5 game thread *It's over!*

Just a couple of notes:
- a doctor who can protect themselves is over-powered as they are effectively un-nightkillable
- revealling Lunar "not"-death gave the town an extra confirmed which is not desirable.

I thought about if I should let the doctor protect himself. I came to the conclusion that the town didn't have a big chance to win so I decided to let the doctor do that.
The reason they won was because Razzorman was really lucky with his investigations.

Also, I didn't think when I wrote that about Lunar. Sorry, I should have replaced his name with *** in the scene and then explained that the doctor rescued "the person".

That's something the host for Mafia 6 should think about.

The reason they won was because Razzorman was really lucky with his investigations.

It wasn't all luck. I investigated budja because he was the most suspicious to me at the time. I investigated bored because lunar was suspicious of him, and because we would gain the most from investigating him.

Also, I hope Razzor doesn't investigate me... if he does...

HE DID.... GAME OVER

How interesting.

Ok, I think Lunar is testing me .

What was this referring to?

Yes, we do have them running in circles, I believe

I just knew you (b2d) had written that note.
Had Razzor not revealed that he was inv and budja maf I would never have suspected budja. I suppose your playstyle is just too similar to mine.

Well, not much else to say. Good job. I had fun writing those notes (especially the second one ). Guess it's off to that werewolf version? Or just a standard mafia? If so... who will host?

I reserved a spot as mafia 6 host, but looks like 20-player werewolf world is taking over.

Quote from: Budja

Ok, I think Lunar is testing me .

What was this referring to?

Quote from: Bored

Yes, we do have them running in circles, I believe

I just knew you (b2d) had written that note.
Had Razzor not revealed that he was inv and budja maf I would never have suspected budja. I suppose your playstyle is just too similar to mine.

Breaking down and analyzing even after the game..

One thing that surprised me was that the Mafia sent me a detailed text explaining how they killed their victim. That wasn't specified in the rules, but I remember that we did so in the first mafia(s). So let's continue with it!
The text was as following:

As a citizen of Nifftown sits quietly dining in peace, a shadow from the streets slips into the house. All is silent for the citizen, as his death, unbeknownst to him, approaches. He leaves to relieve himself, and while he is gone, the shadow slips some poison into his drink. Then, the shadow is gone in a flash, without anyone ever knowing it was there. As the citizen drinks, he begins to choke, then cough up blood. Slowly, he dies. He tries to make it to the hospital, but doesn't even make it to his door. The next morning, his body was found, drowning in a pool of blood. Upon investigation, a note is found, one that says:
Fools. Purple Pineapple was on to me. I'm sure of it. What you may have thought was the ravings of a mad man was, in fact, correct. He knew who I was, though he was careful to not reveal it. I'm positive he was onto me. Just you wait. You'll all die one day... one day soon

[My edit:] Purple Pineapple, Townie, killed night 1.

Look, I'm sorry, ok... no hard feelings? We're both dead now... you're in Heaven, me, being mafia, am probably in...

I thought about if I should let the doctor protect himself. I came to the conclusion that the town didn't have a big chance to win so I decided to let the doctor do that.

The town was more powerful than you think. The setup (without self-protect) looked reasonably balanced.

What was this referring to?

Your questioning of me over my cop ideas early day 2.

I suppose your playstyle is just too similar to mine.

I really thought you suspected me .

I actually did think my ideas were reasonable from a town perspective, I only used them to kick start discussion and I was hoping someone would comment badly and look scummy for it.

I cant believe that I got lynched first day for being inactive.

In case you haven't noticed, the first day is almost always an inactive lynch.

I think we should start a new game. Signups, PP? Also, I'll host mafia 6.5, I think (a .5 game is a really fun, but really... different game. lots of surprises, more roles!!!)

Y'allright. I seem to now have stolen hosting position for Mafia and DWYW. Oh well. Hosting is fun.

That was really fast