I'm surprised that PP died... he seemed like he was helping the mafia with his initial randomness. Anyway, my current, very confused thoughts:
Fools. Purple Pineapple was on to me. I'm sure of it. What you may have thought was the ravings of a mad man was, in fact, correct. He knew who I was, though he was careful to not reveal it. I'm positive he was onto me. Just you wait. You'll all die one day... one day soon
I really don't know what to think of this note. Perhaps the mafia are toying with us, trying to lead the trail to someone Purple Pineapple suspected... which would be me, Mathexpert (who isn't even in the game!), or Lunar. However, it seems to also have been written by someone who was overly paranoid that PP was onto them, or at least trying to LEAD us onto their trails... in which case, we could probably rule out Data for voting, because he was the only one who actually voted for PP, and he did so without much explanation, and he seems to be the one who the note is really trying to get us to lynch, the way it's written. On the other hand, this may be EXACTLY what the mafia WANT us to do. Perhaps Data's a mafia member, who is abusing the fact that someone would point out, the way I did, that we shouldn't trust this note. This is almost like the whole "which comes first, the chicken or the egg" kind of thing. We don't really know whom to vote... either the note is telling the truth, or part of the truth, or, more likely, it is a lie. However, it's also possible that the mafia are having fun and don't really care what happens, or are willing to risk telling the truth... I really don't know. It'd help if we had more time to live... but with Limelemon's random lynching upon the end of the day, we HAVE to catch a mafia member today. These mafia members DO seem to blend in pretty well, whoever they are.
If the cop's out there, then they should know who SOMEONE is, but unless we are about to lynch a townie OR the cop knows who a mafia is, I just realized something: if any of us vote, and it happens to be a townie, then both mafia can join the bandwagon and we lose in an instant. We have got to find out who's guilty before any of us make a vote. This will definitely be tricky...
@Lunar: why have you been opposed to me since your very first post? I give out all my thoughts on whats happening as the thoughts occur to me. You kept your vote throughout the entire day one, without really explaining it. Now, though you say:
I haven't got a single read, and wouldn't be comfortable with any lynch. Although since its pretty much LyLo, if I were forced to lynch at this point I would vote... hm. I don't know. Razzor seemed himself D1. So did Bored even though his usual self isn't quite perfect town. Shawn is quiet.
Basically D1 inactivity leaves me without a clear path, and since we're pretty much at the end of the game... eh. I think I was suspicious of Budja, it was like a week ago though. So the mafia gained hugely by the hiatus.
You still say:
I'd try my luck, seriously, by voting Bored out.
Why? Explain. I let it go day one because it was initially a random vote, but you've stuck with it. Please explain.
Also:
Since we lose if two more kills are made, it seems logical that for now, we strive to the goal that we don't lynch anyone D2. It definitely is an easier target than lynching mafia. Although lynching is a very important tool, I feel, in this case, that we would be foolish to vote without certainty. So I think our D2 tactic should be to stir up a good discussion and see where it takes us, but be extra --
Yeah.
Wait, Salmoneous was lynched because day 1 ended, right? Not because he got 4 votes or whatever?
I'm also pretty sure that the seer saw PP last night. I seriously doubt we will be getting anything from him today.
What exactly was this about? This seems weird, considering that above, you said you'd try your luck by voting me. It also seems weird that you tell people what you WOULD do, but you don't even DO anything except comment on things. You wait till someone else votes, so it doesn't seem like you were to eager to vote someone away, then you eventually join when it won't lead to indicating you being scummy. Seems suspicious...
Also, on a side note, I'm surprised I didn't die last night... it would've thrown suspicion on Lunar_Tick, regardless of whether he was guilty or not, with how opposed he was to me. Of course, if he WAS mafia, then he wouldn't kill me, because of that very fact... Right now, I have my FOS on Lunar_Tick, but will not vote yet till I see where everyone else stands, in case he is not, and the real mafia members joined the bandwagon and lynched him...
Also, explain how today isn't as LyLo as we think, please. It was probably a typo on Limelemon's part, because the normal rules are outnumbering or equalling the town for a mafia win... unless it was changed, but... maybe today isn't a LyLo for Lunar_Tick? Maybe a lynch of a townie would equal victory for Lunar_Tick, or as close to it as possible? I don't know.
@Budja: While a mass claim MIGHT narrow it down some, if we did so and STILL lynched a townie, then the mafia would know who everyone's role was, and they'd be able to kill anyone that they pleased, just about, and the doctor wouldn't know who to protect... I personally am opposed to this plan, because I can see potential cons weighing down potential pros.
@Razzor: What are your thoughts? You merely ask Budja one little question, completely ignoring all other events that happened. Why?
@Shawn: Love to hear from you. The more info we have, the more opinions, the easier it will be for us to lynch the right person.
@Data: What are your thoughts? What do you think of this note that seems to point in your direction? What do you think of Budja's idea?