On Lunar: By your past style of play, I am referring to the providing all facts before voting. You started the game the opposite way, by random voting right away. I hadn't, personally, seen you random vote before, so it was a shock. However, now you're acting like you used to again, posting your thoughts on everyone. Therefore, my later statement would contradict my earlier one, because NOW you're acting like you have in the past games. Also, on PP: I think that he doesn't seem like scum, but this might be his way of protecting himself... there are still not enough facts to vote and be certain enough that we will hunt out scum.
On Budja: are you crazy? The cop reveals himself? Yes, it'd be nice to be reassured that the investigator lives each night, and isn't killed, but doing so will insure that the mafia will be able to kill anyone else, including the doctor. I understand that you're trying to introduce a new strategy, but it wouldn't work all that well. I agree with Lunar_Tick and Razzorman on this issue. Now, what would be even better, perhaps, would be if we could have the investigator write an anonymous note, and Limelemon puts it up after it's written, like in the morning, or before someone's lynched or something. Of course, this would work better in a bigger game, where the mafia don't have a good chance of killing the investigator the first night... which would basically end the game right there. It would be nice if we did have more players...
On Salmoneous: where are you? Are you perchance waiting for the night, so you can fulfill some devious (or investigative) actions? It seems kind of suspicious...
On PP: While I don't think he's scum, necessarily, his attitude doesn't seem the most pro-town. By trying to get us to lynch Mathexpert, who isn't even in the game, he's trying to get us to waste a valuable lynching opportunity, the best we actually have at the moment. With this short of a game, we need to hit the mafia day one, or one of our power roles may be taken out, and then we're basically sitting ducks, with a very small chance of victory. This is why I find his actions strange.
On Razzorman: Doesn't seem very strange yet, though his posts each only concentrate on one thing that's been said, usually something, though, that would hurt the town if it was followed through (ie, voting for mathexpert, or the cop claiming right away). I'm not sure what to think, though he seems pro town.
On Data: I've noticed that you said the whole paranoid random vote thing, but THEN you supplied a reason for voting for PP. You contradict yourself there, because it's not entirely random if you have SOME reason. Seems a little bit scummy, but mostly town.
On Shawn: haven't seen much activity from you, what are your thoughts on everything? Might be in the same boat as Salmoneous... waiting till the night, when he can perform some action... seems a little scummy, but if you haven't been able to get on, then it's understandable.
On Bored: Do you guys really trust him? I mean, come on! Everything he says contradicts himself, he's trying to use REASON to vote and root out the scum, he's trying to keep an open mind so he doesn't ignore clues as to who the scum is, and he has a pokeplushie that he had before the game, and it's named Grim. OBVIOusly he's scum, I mean, come on. Vote: Bored2death (notice, it's not in bold
)