Mafia 4 day 2

...what now?

Well now we start a new game. Presumably with Limelemon leading.

If we have a new game I think it should be old mafia without all the new roles and that. Like the first mafia we had with Nifflas as a GM.

Edit: Just so you all know, I was a citizen.

Seeing how pitifully I failed, I guess this game's over.
I thought I could pull it off, but in the end, failed like a blob of waste.  X(
I guess this is the end of my nifforum life.

Only you are being hard on youself. This didn't fail at all.

Well, roles like investigator and doctor are good. And I liked the idea of Masons (two Citizens who know each other to be innocent and can talk to each other at night) from the Mafias on the old forum.

I was an investigator, the one who investigated Salmoneous- and I got a 'guilty' result.

Explain please?

I was an investigator, the one who investigated Salmoneous- and I got a 'guilty' result.

Explain please?

Maybe he is lying in case the game goes on.

I don't think there's any chance of that. NES left and he didn't hand the game over to anybody, so now nobody knows who anybody is and any attempt to resume it would only result in disorder. Even if a new mod decides to take it over, and asks everyone to PM him what their roles were, people will probably decide that they were in fact doctors / roleblockers / investigators. (Well, they probably wouldn't, to be fair to everyone, but it's too much of a possibility.) Hopefully a new one will start soon, though

I was an investigator, the one who investigated Salmoneous- and I got a 'guilty' result.

That's weird.

Here is the pm I received from NES

You are a typical townie.
All you can do is vote and hope you hang the mafia.  Victory is yours when all threats to town are gone.

Why would I lie when the game is over?

Strange. Maybe NES just messed up the investigation? Eh well.

On a hunch for now.
vote: Purple Pineapple
He apologised to me for defending victor and I feel this is quite odd. Did anyone else get a simular message?

Nope. And I don't blame you for voting me. I'd find myself quite suspicious now, aswell.

Quote from: Dataflashsabot on August 14, 2009, 22:13:42

I was an investigator, the one who investigated Salmoneous- and I got a 'guilty' result.

That's weird.

Here is the pm I received from NES

Quote

You are a typical townie.
All you can do is vote and hope you hang the mafia.  Victory is yours when all threats to town are gone.

Why would I lie when the game is over?

This post just made me think of something. What with the night-time phone calls, everyone could just PM their role assignments from NES to each other. Whomever refused or sent a different town PM would obviously have a special role.

You have got to be kidding me  .
Well, now that people are posting role PM's, the game is pretty much unsalvagable to me

Data is probably a paranoid cop, one who gets a guilty on innocents.

Ok, NES you did screw up a bit but it happens, don't be too hard on yourself please.

Things I think you should not do as mod:

 - Post all night actions: Seriously don't, you won't believe how much that helps the mafia.
 - The 1-week day deadline. You shouldn't have changed the rules for this part way through. Unless the setup had more town PR's, it is massively in the mafia's favour.
 - If you use roles which are not played here, please say so. Thats why a used a semi-open setup with a list of all possible roles so those unsure of many mafia roles don't get confused.

This post just made me think of something. What with the night-time phone calls, everyone could just PM their role assignments from NES to each other. Whomever refused or sent a different town PM would obviously have a special role.

Hence the rule against quoting mod PM's, nighttalk isn't really good unless it is a specific part of a role anyway.

Something that might interest you. The mafia were allowed full day-talk and we used it. If the game continued I am pretty sure we would have won.
http://www.quicktopic.com/43/H/uh2B6V28rLE

I sort of figured that my post would have shown who I was.

Oh well.

I was the Jester. It's a really confusing role.

...I was actively being inactive. 

Wait.. there actually was a Jester?!

Town never had a chance .

I was the Jester. It's a really confusing role.

...I was actively being inactive. 

Well, you fooled me.