Mafia 4 day 2

I'm aware of that.

FoS victor, come out of the shadows .

@all who haven't commented, what do you think of Limelemon?

undo mah fos and FoS limelemon.

Victor, that doesn't answer any questions.

FoS victor12

I doubt barking up Victor's tree will result in anything but wasting our time. Previous games have validated this. I have no idea what role Victor is, but due to his silent and disjointed  playstyle, I don't think we will gain anything by asking him questions.

I suppose this is great grounds for lynching, since we will be removing dead weight (slightly different from silent players) from the town. At the moment its impossible to gauge his role, so that may prove interesting.

Anyway, I'd rather lynch Victor for his sleepy playstyle rather than (say) Limelemon's more avantgarde, more suspicious but more talkative style.

Also, I feel we've been dwelling way too long on Victor's behaviour.

Koromi's post eludes me.

i'm not trying to say because it's the same person that did the outbursts in both occasions that it is more likely the circumstances are exactly the same.

i am saying that it is common strategy to try something more than once.

These two sentences seem to contradict each other.
In one sentence, Koromi says that we cannot claim that the two situations are similar (just because the two situations pertain the same person, LL).
In the other sentence, Koromi provides evidence that supports the claim that the two situation are similar (because the two situations pertain the same person, LL).

Is this some kind of strange rhetorical tactic, or?


Again:

and most importantly: lunar_tick, mafia is all about assuming, especially on the first day.

Reading this after reading the part of my post #45 on Koromi, it seems that he states an opinion and disagrees with me: that we ought to assume (generally) about things in the game, and also we ought to assume (more specifically now) that the two incidents of LL behaviour are similar, and should be treated as such.



I wouldn't like to comment more on this because, naturally, Koromi (among others) has to come in and sort it out, however I will say that the assertion

mafia is all about assuming, especially on the first day.

should not be held as a golden rule, as it possibly leads to a bad attitude. This bad attitude is essentially believing that in a game of Mafia you can't really have any tangible and proper evidence, so let's just go with our gut instinct rather than ask questions or try to obtain what we see as the impossible.

FoS victor, come out of the shadows .

That is indeed rather out of the shadows, seeing as victor just happens to be the one lucky inactive to draw attention. FOS:Budja

@all who haven't commented, what do you think of Limelemon?

It's seems like LimeLemon started by being random and people got suspicious of that. The majority of his remaining posts were self defense against koromi's accusation.

What's wrong with a little pressure? Although Lunar is probably right that we won't get much out of victor.

@Purple Pineapple, I want your opinion.

On what?

LimeLemon .

I think, among others, that Salmoneous, Technogeek, Dataflashabot and Sabata should pipe up.

My opinion is that there's not really and evidence on which to lynch LimeLemon. He doesn't seem particularly suspicious to me. Maybe got a bit carried away, but not really in a mafia way.

I think that LimeLemon's behavior, though suspicious, shows that he's not mafia, and likely to be the jester, because he's drawing attention to himself. Of course he could be doing that to throw us off track.

Victor12 just seems too silent; I doubt that lynching him would lead to any bad results.

Still, I'm not going to vote / FOS yet.

Victor12 just seems too silent; I doubt that lynching him would lead to any bad results.

In total agreement.

Still, I'm not going to vote / FOS yet.

Yeah, I'll vote after the next votecount.


Or not. Victor12

Well, I've been quite busy lately and haven't really paid much attention to the game (oh noes don't nightkill me Lunar_Tick!), but looking over the thread reveals that a lot of people have been acting pretty suspiciously.

I think I'm going to vote:victor12. There's really not much to go on. He doesn't seem very helpful anyways. Of course, there's a slight possibility he's the jester- silence will eventually get you lynched. I guess I'll have to take that risk.